Wager Mage
Photo by Andres  Ayrton Pexels Logo Photo: Andres Ayrton

What size is bigger 1 2 or 1 3?

As such, 1/2 is always greater than 1/3 regardless of the context.

bstockus.wordpress.com - Is 1/2 always greater than 1/3?
Do casinos have cameras?
Do casinos have cameras?

It's no secret that casinos are some of the most watched places on the planet. In a casino, hundreds of cameras are installed throughout every...

Read More »
Has anyone ever won a 12 team parlay?
Has anyone ever won a 12 team parlay?

It was $50 to win $21,560 on seven MLB games, three NBA games and two NHL games. He or she won, which is remarkable in itself. You can go your...

Read More »

Lately I’ve been reading the book Beyond Pizzas & Pies: 10 Essential Strategies for Supporting Fraction Sense by Julie McNamara and Meghan Shaughnessy. My colleague, Hedge, replied about being challenged by a middle school teacher on this very issue. I let her know I was also challenged about this idea several years ago when I was a digital curriculum developer. The argument I heard back then was that using contexts to validate the correctness of fraction comparisons ran counter to the fact that fractions are numbers. As such, 1/2 is always greater than 1/3 regardless of the context. At the time, I wondered about it, but I still felt that bringing context to bear was important. Flash forward to now and I have been mulling this idea over all day. I think I may finally understand why we have to be careful what we say about the role of context when comparing fractions. I may be completely off the mark, but I’m going to share my thoughts anyway and let you decide in the comments if you’d like to challenge my thinking or share an alternative point of view. Let’s start with whole numbers. If I told you to compare 3 and 6, you would probably tell me, “3 is less than 6,” or, “6 is greater than 3.” That is how the numbers 3 and 6 are related. Now, what if I were to show you these two pictures of 3 and 6: (As illustrated by my daughter’s toys.) Technically, the 3 dolls are larger and therefore they amount to more stuff, but does that really mean 3 is now greater than 6? In the end, the number of dolls my daughter has (3) is less than the number of figurines she has (6). The context doesn’t fundamentally change the relationship between the numbers 3 and 6. In this case, I don’t even know how I’d justify that she has more when referring to the dolls. Sure, they’re bigger, but she may prefer to have more things to play with and choose the 6 figurines even though they are less in total size. Let’s continue by looking at this from a fraction perspective. Now I’m going to take 1/3 of the dolls and 1/2 of the figurines.

What is the minimum and maximum limit of bonus?
What is the minimum and maximum limit of bonus?

Maximum and minimum bonus According to the Bonus Payment Act, a minimum bonus of 8.33% of wage or salary earned by the employee for an accounting...

Read More »
How do I avoid paying taxes on casino winnings?
How do I avoid paying taxes on casino winnings?

In gambling, there are winners and losers. But even the winners can be losers if they don't pay their taxes! Any money you win while gambling or...

Read More »

In keeping with the idea that context should dictate when one number is greater than another, I should be convinced that 1/3 of the dolls is greater than 1/2 of the figurines because 1 doll is so much larger than the 3 figurines. Oh wait, or is it that I should be thinking that 1/2 of the figurines is greater than 1/3 of the dolls because I end up with 3 figurines which is a greater number of things than 1 doll? It’s not so clear cut, even though I’m trying to let the context dictate how to interpret the fractions. What it boils down to is that fractions represent a relationship. If I think about the relationships each fraction represents, then 1/2 is always greater than 1/3 no matter how I try to spin it. Looking back at my examples, taking 1/2 of the group of figurines means I am taking a greater share of that group (that whole) than when I take 1/3 of the group of dolls (a different whole, but a whole nonetheless). The size of the things in my group (whole) doesn’t matter because the relationship represented by 1/2 is greater than the relationship represented by 1/3. Now, does that mean we should ignore contexts altogether? No. There are still rich conversations to be had about who ate more pizza when one person eats half of a small pizza and another person eats a third of a large pizza. Context is still interesting to discuss and helps students use math to interpret the world around them. However, if our goal is to compare fractions, then 1/2 is greater than 1/3 every time.

That’s the argument I came up with today as I tried to understand the criticisms I’ve heard. Now that you’ve read it, what do you think?

bstockus.wordpress.com - Is 1/2 always greater than 1/3?
How many lines should I use in slots?
How many lines should I use in slots?

The features and exciting wins are part of the fun of gambling on slots. And ultimately, you can win more on 5 reel slots than on 3 reels....

Read More »
Do casinos control who wins?
Do casinos control who wins?

So, at its high level, slot machines are controlled by gaming regulators by the placement of legal requirements for payout return percentages....

Read More »
What are the seven 7 tips for success?
What are the seven 7 tips for success?

Seven Steps to Success Seven Steps to Success. There is a powerful seven-step formula that you can use to set and achieve your goals for the rest...

Read More »
What is 3 to 2 payout?
What is 3 to 2 payout?

Somewhere on the blackjack table there will be a sign that says, "blackjack pays 3 to 2". All this means is that you, the player, will get $3 for...

Read More »